
Questions about criminal forensic accounting
Questions
Short, direct answers to the questions defence teams most often ask before instructing a forensic accountant.
What does a criminal forensic accountant do?
A criminal forensic accountant analyses the financial evidence in a criminal case and gives independent expert opinion to the court. Typical work includes tracing funds, testing prosecution schedules, quantifying loss or benefit, and preparing evidence for confiscation proceedings.
Who instructs a criminal forensic accountant?
Most instructions come from defence solicitors on behalf of individual or corporate defendants. Prosecuting and regulatory authorities also instruct independent experts. In every case the expert's overriding duty is to the court, not to the party paying.
What rules apply to expert evidence in criminal cases?
Expert evidence in criminal proceedings is governed by Part 19 of the Criminal Procedure Rules and its practice direction. The report must set out the expert's qualifications, the material relied on, the reasoning, any range of opinion and a declaration of the expert's duty to the court.
Can you work on legally aided cases?
Yes. We provide a written scope and fee estimate so that the instructing solicitor can apply for prior authority before work starts.
How long does a forensic accounting report take?
It depends on the volume of records and the questions asked. We agree a timetable at the outset that fits the court directions and tell you if the material served changes it.
Is the first conversation confidential?
Yes. Initial enquiries are treated as confidential. Please send only a short outline of the matter until a conflict check is complete.
When should a forensic accountant be instructed in a fraud case?
As early as possible, ideally once the prosecution has served its financial evidence. Early review helps the defence understand the strength of the figures, identify missing disclosure and decide whether expert evidence is needed for trial.
Can you check the prosecution's loss figure?
Yes. We trace the loss figure back to the source records, test the method used and recalculate it where the records support a different figure.
What is the difference between benefit and the available amount?
Benefit is the value the defendant is found to have obtained from crime. The available amount is what the defendant can actually pay from their assets. The order is made for the lower of the two, so both figures matter.
Can a forensic accountant challenge hidden asset findings?
We examine the financial trail the prosecution relies on and set out, from the records, what happened to the money. Where funds were spent, lost or never existed, the analysis can support the defence case that there are no hidden assets.
Can unusual transactions have an innocent explanation?
Often, yes. Cash-based businesses, family transfers and informal lending can produce patterns that look suspicious in isolation. Our analysis puts the transactions in the context of the wider records so the court can see the full picture.
Is the tax loss in the indictment always accurate?
Not necessarily. Tax loss figures often rest on estimates and assumptions. Recalculating the figure from the records can reduce it, and the difference matters both at trial and in any later confiscation proceedings.
Do you act for companies as well as individuals?
Yes. We provide expert evidence for individual defendants and corporate defendants, subject to a conflict check at the outset of every instruction.
Can a forensic accountant help release funds for a business?
We can set out the business's genuine trading requirements from its records, which supports an application to the court. Whether funds are released is a matter for the court.
Do you accept legally aided instructions?
Yes. We provide a written scope and fee estimate so that instructing solicitors can apply for prior authority before work begins.
Discuss a matter in confidence
Send a short outline of the matter. We will confirm whether we are free to act and how we can help.