In short: Benefit is the value a defendant is found to have obtained from crime. It is assessed either on the particular offences or, where the defendant has a criminal lifestyle, on general criminal conduct using statutory assumptions. Both routes depend on financial evidence that can be tested.
Two routes to a benefit figure
After conviction, the court decides whether the defendant has a criminal lifestyle. If not, benefit is limited to what was obtained from the particular criminal conduct. If so, the court looks at general criminal conduct and applies assumptions to property transferred to or held by the defendant over a set period.
The difference is significant. Under the lifestyle route, ordinary deposits, purchases and expenditure can be treated as benefit unless the defendant shows they came from a legitimate source or the court finds a serious risk of injustice.
Where the figures go wrong
Prosecution benefit calculations are usually prepared from bank statements and asset searches. Common problems include:
- Counting the same money twice as it moves between accounts
- Treating loans, family transfers or business takings as benefit without considering their source
- Using gross receipts where the evidence supports a smaller obtained amount
- Valuing property at the wrong date or on the wrong basis
What a forensic accountant adds
A forensic accountant reconciles the prosecution schedule to the source records, separates genuine benefit from internal transfers, and documents legitimate income where the records allow. The result is a figure the court can test line by line.
Because the confiscation order is made for the lower of benefit and the available amount, the same analysis should also look at what assets genuinely exist and what they are worth.
